In the SPCA's view, the use of electric collars on dogs is not only unnecessary, cruel and inhumane but also causes harm to the animal. The Society also condemns the use of such devices.

The Electric Collar, or e-collar, gives an electric shock to the dog whenever it demonstrates unacceptable behaviour. Each time a shock is delivered, it can also cause unnecessary pain, stress and suffering to the dog. The use of electric collars is merely a `quick fix' approach to controlling a dog's behaviour. This form of training is no substitute for training based on understanding and love, coupled with the establishment of a rewarding and trusting relationship. Even the Police Dog Unit and the Singapore Armed Forces do not resort to using electric collars to train their working dogs, as they prefer the method of `motivation and conditioning.'

Australia has banned the importation of electric collars and such devices and anyone found using them can be prosecuted. In 1999 SPCA Singapore had supported the Singapore Kennel Club's proposal to the government, that a ban of these collars be introduced, but without success. The Primary Production Department (now called the Agri-food & Veterinary Authority), although not banning the use of the collars at that time, said that it would not hesitate to take action against any person found to be using an electric collar cruelly and in an abusive manner, to hurt a dog.

Please Note: The SPCA advises all dog owners not to engage services of any dog trainer who uses electric dog collar. Anyone who had witness misuse of this devic is adviced to contact SPCA at 6287 5355 ext. 26 to lodge a complaint of cruel to animals.